Lifestyle
September 13, 2025

Best Coffee Shops in St. James, NY: Local Spots to Savor

Best Coffee Shops in St. James, NY: Local Spots to Savor

St. James, NY, is a charming hamlet located on Long Island, known for its quaint streets and welcoming community. Among its many attractions, the local coffee shops stand out as delightful spots where residents and visitors can enjoy a warm cup of coffee, a delicious meal, and a moment of relaxation. These establishments not only serve as places to grab a quick caffeine fix but also as community hubs where creativity and connection thrive. Let's explore some of the most inviting coffee shops in St. James, NY, each offering its own unique atmosphere and culinary delights.

Cozy Cafés and Brunch Spots

Soul Brew - St. James

Soul Brew - St. James is a beloved café located in the heart of St. James. Known for its organic fair-trade coffee and all-day brunch menu, Soul Brew offers a welcoming atmosphere that encourages relaxation and connection. The café's menu caters to both vegetarians and vegans, with creative options like the Feelin’ Tot Burrito and Soul’s Breakfast Platter. The commitment to quality ingredients and the vibrant ambiance make it a must-visit spot for brunch enthusiasts and coffee lovers alike. Whether you're looking to enjoy a leisurely brunch or simply want to savor a cup of expertly brewed coffee, Soul Brew provides a culinary experience filled with good vibes.

Basil Cafe

Located at 413 Lake Ave, Basil Cafe is a charming eatery that offers a delightful dining experience for both locals and visitors. The café is known for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, making it an ideal spot for a cozy lunch or a relaxed dinner. Open from Tuesday to Saturday between 12 pm and 9 pm, and on Sundays from 4 pm to 8 pm, Basil Cafe provides a convenient location for those exploring St. James. With the ease of making reservations via phone, diners can enjoy a seamless experience. Whether you're in search of a comforting meal or a place to unwind, Basil Cafe stands out as a must-visit destination in St. James.

Level Up Kitchen

Nestled within the Flowerfield complex, Level Up Kitchen is a vibrant eatery that offers a wide range of meals, including breakfast, lunch, and coffee. Open weekdays from 8 am to 6 pm, it is perfect for those looking for a quick grab-and-go experience. The kitchen also features a unique "Pentimento Pop-up" on Monday evenings, offering a rotating selection of favorite dishes. Level Up Kitchen extends its services with customizable catering options, available for both delivery and pickup within the Flowerfield area. Additionally, it has a presence at the Emma S. Clark Memorial Library in Setauket, where it offers a selection of handmade food items, beverages, and freshly-baked pastries. This local gem is a must-visit for anyone in the St. James area looking for quality meals and a welcoming atmosphere.

Unique Coffee Experiences

Soul Brew's Creative Menu

Soul Brew's creative menu is one of its standout features, offering a wide selection of dishes that cater to various dietary preferences. The café's commitment to using quality ingredients ensures that each dish is both flavorful and satisfying. The Feelin’ Tot Burrito, for example, is a popular choice among patrons, combining crispy tater tots with scrambled eggs, cheese, and a medley of fresh vegetables. For those seeking a hearty breakfast, Soul’s Breakfast Platter provides a delicious assortment of eggs, bacon, and toast, all prepared with care and attention to detail. The café's innovative approach to brunch makes it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Basil Cafe's Cozy Atmosphere

Basil Cafe is renowned for its cozy atmosphere, which invites diners to relax and enjoy their meals in comfort. The café's interior is tastefully decorated, creating a warm and inviting environment that complements the delicious food on offer. Whether you're stopping by for a leisurely lunch or a casual dinner, Basil Cafe provides a welcoming space where you can unwind and savor the moment. The friendly service further enhances the dining experience, ensuring that each visit is a pleasant one.

Level Up Kitchen's Pop-Up Events

Level Up Kitchen's "Pentimento Pop-up" events are a unique feature that sets it apart from other eateries in the area. These events, held on Monday evenings, offer a rotating selection of favorite dishes, providing diners with the opportunity to try something new and exciting each week. The pop-up events are a testament to the kitchen's creativity and commitment to offering a wide range of culinary experiences. Whether you're a regular patron or a first-time visitor, these events provide a delightful way to explore the kitchen's offerings in a fun and engaging setting.

Community Hubs

Soul Brew's Welcoming Environment

At Soul Brew, the focus is not just on serving great coffee and food but also on creating a welcoming environment where community and creativity can thrive. The café's inviting atmosphere encourages patrons to relax, connect, and rejuvenate their spirits. Whether you're meeting friends for brunch or simply enjoying a quiet moment with a book, Soul Brew provides a space where you can feel at home. The café's dedication to fostering a sense of community makes it a beloved spot in St. James.

Basil Cafe's Convenient Location

Basil Cafe's convenient location on Lake Avenue makes it easily accessible to both locals and visitors exploring St. James. The café's central position allows diners to enjoy a meal before or after visiting nearby attractions, making it a popular choice for those looking to experience the charm of the area. With the option to make reservations via phone, Basil Cafe ensures that diners can plan their visits with ease, enhancing the overall dining experience.

Level Up Kitchen's Library Presence

Level Up Kitchen's presence at the Emma S. Clark Memorial Library in Setauket is a unique aspect of its operations, offering patrons a selection of handmade food items, beverages, and freshly-baked pastries. This collaboration allows library visitors to enjoy delicious treats while exploring the library's offerings, creating a delightful synergy between the two establishments. The kitchen's commitment to providing quality meals and a welcoming atmosphere extends beyond its main location, making it a valued part of the St. James community.

Discover the Best Coffee Spots in St. James, NY

Exploring the coffee shops in St. James, NY, offers more than just a caffeine fix; it's an opportunity to immerse yourself in the local culture and community spirit. From the creative menus at Soul Brew to the cozy ambiance of Basil Cafe and the unique pop-up events at Level Up Kitchen, each spot provides a unique experience. Whether you're a local or just visiting, these cafés are perfect for relaxing and connecting. If you're considering making St. James your home, reach out to the experts at Northshore Home Advisory for guidance on finding the perfect place to settle in this charming hamlet.

Similar Articles

View all posts

Work With North Shore Advisory at BHS

Follow Us